top of page

Diminished Responsibility

32 minutes ago
7 min read
Diminished responsibility
Diminished Responsibility

Diminished responsibility is a partial defence to murder. It can be used when a defendant has killed another person but their actions of killing that person were caused by an abnormality of mental functioning.


If the defence of diminished responsibility is successful, the defendant will be found guilty of voluntary manslaughter rather than murder. This is important because murder carries a mandatory life sentence, whereas manslaughter gives the judge greater flexibility when deciding the appropriate sentence. The judge can therefore impose a sentence that takes account of the defendant's mental condition and level of responsibility.


The Law on Diminished Responsibility

Diminished responsibility is defined in Section 2(1) of the Homicide Act 1957, as amended by Section 52 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009.


Under this legislation, a defendant will not be convicted of murder if they can prove that, at the time of the killing, they were suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning which:

  • Arose from a recognised medical condition.

  • Substantially impaired their ability to:

    • Understand the nature of their conduct; or

    • Form a rational judgment; or

    • Exercise self-control.

  • Provides an explanation for their acts or omissions in carrying out the killing.


There are four main stages to the test for diminished responsibility. The defendant must establish that all four requirements are satisfied.


Stage 1: Abnormality Of Mental Functioning

The first stage requires the defendant to prove that they were suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning at the time of the killing, as stated in Section 52 (1) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009, This means that at the time that they committed the killing their brain functioning was different to that of the average human being.


In R v Byrne (1960), the defendant was charged with murdering a young woman by strangling her and mutilating her body. He argued that he suffered from an abnormality of mind because he experienced powerful sexual urges that he found extremely difficult to control. The court held that an abnormality of mental functioning has been defined as a state of mind that is so different from that of an ordinary human being that the reasonable person would deem it abnormal.


The defendant must also provide medical evidence to support their claim that they were suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning.

In R v Bunch (2013), the defendant relied on diminished responsibility following a killing and argued that he was suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning. The medical evidence did not sufficiently establish the abnormality required for the defence. The case demonstrates that a defendant cannot rely on simply claiming that their mental functioning was abnormal. There must be sufficient medical evidence to support the existence of an abnormality and the requirements of diminished responsibility.


Stage 2: Recognised Medical Condition

Under Section 52(1)(a) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009, the defendant’s abnormality of mental functioning must come from a recognised medical condition. Recognised Medical Conditions are psychological or physical health conditions that are listed in the World Health Organisation (WHO) International Classification of Diseases. Examples of psychological conditions are depression, battered spouse syndrome, schizophrenia and PTSD.


Stage 3: Substantial Impairment

The third stage requires the defendant to prove that their abnormality of mental functioning arose from a recognised medical condition and that this condition substantially impaired at least one of the three abilities identified in Section 52 (1A) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009.


The abnormality must also have substantially impaired at least one of the following three abilities:

  • Section 52 (1A) (a) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009: Understanding the nature of their conduct

    • This means the defendant's ability to understand what they were physically doing or the nature of their actions. Their medical condition must have substantially affected their ability to understand the nature of their behaviour.

  • Section 52 (1A) (b) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009: Forming a rational judgment

    • This means the defendant's ability to think logically and make reasonable decisions. Their medical condition must have substantially affected their ability to make rational decisions about their actions.

  • Section 52 (1A) (c) of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009: Exercising self-control

    • This means the defendant's ability to control their behaviour and resist acting on certain thoughts, feelings or impulses. Their medical condition must have substantially affected their ability to control their actions.


The defendant only needs to prove that one of these three abilities was substantially impaired. They do not need to prove that all three were affected.


It is important to understand that substantial impairment does not mean total impairment. The defendant does not have to prove that they were completely unable to understand their actions, make rational decisions or exercise self-control. However, the impairment must be significant and more than simply minimal or trivial.


In R v Golds (2016), the defendant had a history of mental health difficulties and killed his partner by repeatedly stabbing her. He relied on diminished responsibility, supported by evidence from two forensic psychiatrists who agreed that he had an abnormality of mental functioning arising from a recognised medical condition. The Supreme Court ruled that substantial means significantly or weightily impaired, and that it requires more than just something more than trivial or minimal.


Stage 4: Provides an Explanation for the Killing

The fourth stage requires the defendant to prove that their abnormality of mental functioning provides an explanation for their acts or omissions in carrying out the killing.


This means there must be a causal link between the defendant's abnormality of mental functioning and the killing. In other words, the medical condition must have played a significant part in explaining why the defendant acted as they did.


The abnormality does not have to be the only reason for the killing. However, it must have caused the defendant to act as they did or have been a significant contributing factor in their actions.


Diminished Responsibility and Intoxication

Intoxication can create difficulties when deciding whether a defendant can rely on diminished responsibility. In theory when a person is intoxicated it can be seen to impair their mental functioning however the courts have been strict and, in most cases, refuse to allow intoxication to be classed as an abnormality of mental functioning.


The courts distinguish between voluntary intoxication, voluntary intoxication alongside a pre-existing abnormality of mental functioning, and alcohol dependency syndrome.


Voluntary Intoxication

If a defendant voluntarily becomes intoxicated through drinking alcohol or taking drugs or taking another intoxicating substance, they cannot rely on the effects of that intoxication alone to establish diminished responsibility.


This is because voluntary intoxication is not, by itself, a recognised medical condition capable of creating the abnormality of mental functioning required by the defence.


In R v Dowds (2012), the defendant had consumed a large amount of alcohol before killing his partner. He argued that his voluntary intoxication had affected his mental functioning and should allow him to rely on diminished responsibility. The Court of Appeal rejected this argument and confirmed that voluntary acute intoxication cannot, by itself, provide the basis for diminished responsibility. The case established that a defendant cannot use the effects of voluntarily consuming alcohol or drugs alone to satisfy the requirements of the defence.


Voluntary Intoxication and a Pre-Existing Abnormality of Mental Functioning

There is a different approach when a defendant has a pre-existing abnormality of mental functioning, here they may still be able to use diminished responsibility even if they voluntarily become intoxicated before the killing.


The important question is whether the pre-existing abnormality of mental functioning substantially impaired the defendant's responsibility for the killing, despite the effects of the alcohol or drugs. The abnormality does not have to be the only factor contributing to the killing, but it must have significantly contributed to the defendant's actions.


In R v Dietschmann (2003), the defendant was suffering from an adjustment disorder following the death of his aunt, with whom he had a close relationship. He became heavily intoxicated and subsequently attacked and killed a man during an argument. The House of Lords held that the defendant could still rely on diminished responsibility if his underlying mental abnormality substantially impaired his responsibility for the killing, even though alcohol had also contributed to his behaviour. The jury had to consider whether the abnormality substantially impaired his responsibility despite the effects of the alcohol.

The case established that voluntary intoxication does not automatically prevent a defendant from relying on diminished responsibility where they have a separate, pre-existing abnormality of mental functioning.


Alcohol Dependency Syndrome

Alcohol Dependency Syndrome (ADS) is a medical condition that can cause an abnormality of mental functioning. It involves a strong dependence on alcohol, which can affect a person's ability to control their drinking.


In some circumstances, a defendant suffering from ADS may be able to use diminished responsibility if their alcohol consumption was driven by their dependency. The important issue is whether the defendant's abnormality of mental functioning, arising from their alcohol dependency, substantially impaired their responsibility for the killing.


In R v Wood (2008), the defendant was a chronic alcoholic who regularly consumed very large quantities of strong cider each day. He killed another person and argued that his alcohol dependency had affected his ability to control his drinking and his mental responsibility for his actions. The Court of Appeal recognised that an irresistible craving for alcohol could make the defendant's drinking involuntary. The case established that diminished responsibility can be a defence if the defendant’s drinking was involuntary due to the Alcohol Dependency Syndrome.


In R v Stewart (2009), the defendant was a chronic alcoholic who was sleeping rough in London. After becoming involved in a drunken fight, he attacked and killed another man, and he relied on alcohol dependency syndrome to support his defence of diminished responsibility. The case established that alcohol dependency does not have to make drinking completely involuntary for diminished responsibility to be available. The jury must consider the overall effect of the defendant's medical condition and whether it substantially impaired their mental responsibility for the killing.


It is important to remember that simply suffering from alcohol dependency syndrome does not automatically mean the defendant can use diminished responsibility. They must still satisfy all the requirements of the defence, including substantial impairment and a causal link between their abnormality of mental functioning and the killing.


Summary of Diminished Responsibility

To successfully use diminished responsibility, the defendant must prove all three stages of the legal test. The defence is not available simply because the defendant has a mental health condition or behaved unusually at the time of the killing.


The three stages are:

  1. Abnormality of mental functioning: The defendant must have been suffering from an abnormality of mental functioning at the time of the killing.

  2. Recognised medical condition and substantial impairment: The abnormality must have arisen from a recognised medical condition which substantially impaired the defendant's ability to understand the nature of their conduct, form a rational judgment or exercise self-control.

  3. Provides an explanation: The abnormality must have caused or significantly contributed to the defendant's actions in carrying out the killing.


If the defendant successfully proves diminished responsibility, they will be convicted of voluntary manslaughter rather than murder. This removes the mandatory life sentence for murder and allows the judge greater flexibility when deciding the appropriate sentence.


Click below to download the FREE TeachLaw student activity pack.

Diminished Responsibility
Free Student Activity Pack


Click below to explore TeachLaw revision resources:

OCR A-Level Law Revision Guide Bundle - Human Rights Option
Buy Now
OCR A-Level Law Revision Guide Bundle - Contract Law Option
Buy Now
AQA A-Level Law Revision Guide Bundle - Human Rights Option
Buy Now
AQA A-Level Law Revision Guide Bundle – Contract Law Option
Buy Now
BTEC Applied Law Unit 3 Revision Guide
Buy Now
BTEC Applied Law Unit 1 Revision Guide
Buy Now

Comments


bottom of page